101 Top Indiana Insurance Companies and Startups of 2021

June 30, 2021
Top Companies (Navigation) show

This article showcases our top picks for the best Indiana based Insurance companies. These startups and companies are taking a variety of approaches to innovating the Insurance industry, but are all exceptional companies well worth a follow.

We tried to pick companies across the size spectrum from cutting edge startups to established brands.

We selected these startups and companies for exceptional performance in one of these categories:

  • Innovation
    • Innovative ideas
    • Innovative route to market
    • Innovative product
  • Growth
    • Exceptional growth
    • Exceptional growth strategy
  • Management
  • Societal impact

[adace-ad id=”7108″]

Top Indiana Insurance Startups

Data sourced from Crunchbase and SemRush.

Advise Insurance

Advise Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Advise Insurance is a Medicare concierge agency that focuses on serving seniors within their community.

Anthem

Anthem

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Anthem operates as a private health insurance organization nationwide.

Anthem

DOXA Insurance Holdings

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

DOXA Insurance Holdings is a private equity fund acquiring small- to medium-size managing general agents.

Anthem

OneMain Holdings

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

OneMain Holdings is a financial company with a focus on credit-related products such as consumer lending and and credit insurance.

Anthem

Alacrity Solutions

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Alacrity Solutions is a full end-to-end service provider that offers insurance claims, repair, and recovery solutions.

Anthem

Maverest Dental Network

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Maverest Dental Network is a network of dentists available for use by insurance companies.

Anthem

International Medical Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

IMG has dedicated its efforts to providing international medical insurance, travel insurance.

Anthem

Protective Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Protective Insurance is an insurance company offering insurance for the transportation industry.

Anthem

Shepherd Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

A privately-owned independent insurance agency.

Anthem

Renaissance Holding Company

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Renaissance Holding Company offers dental insurance products and services.

Anthem

MedPro Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

MedPro Group is the national leader in customized insurance, claims, patient safety, and risk solutions for physicians, surgeons.

Anthem

Beacon Technologies Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Beacon Technologies Group is a software firm that focused on delivering innovative health claims management solutions.

Anthem

First Merchants

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Frst merchants is a multi- bank holding company

Eversurance, LLC

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Eversurance, LLC is a health insurance agency.

Anthem

Squaremouth

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Squaremouth is an online company that compares travel insurance products from every major provider in the United States.

Anthem

K&K Insurance Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

K&K Insurance is a leading provider of specialty insurance products.

Anthem

PetFirst Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

PetFirst is the fastest-growing pet health insurance company .

Anthem

Eagle Adjusting Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

A Noblesville, Ind.-based property and casualty claims adjusting company

Anthem

Seven Corners

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

An innovative and service focused international travel insurance and specialty benefit management company.

Anthem

Arlington/Roe & Co

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Arlington/Roe & Co is an insurance company that offers mobile home and recreational vehicle insurance.

Anthem

AgencyRoot

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

SaaS for SMB in Agriculture

Anthem

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company offers multiple commercial insurance programs, legal assistance and property protection technology.

Anthem

Fuzion

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Fuzion is an information technology company offering insurance data analytics services.

Anthem

Physicians Health Plan of Northern Indiana (PHP)

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Physicians Health Plan of Northern Indiana is an insurance company that offers health insurance products and services.

Anthem

ONI Risk Partners

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

ONI Risk Partners is the insurance agency.

Anthem

Centier bank

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Centier Bank is a banking company that offers loans, investments, insurance and other financial services.

Anthem

Old National Insurance (ONI)

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Old National Insurance (“ONI”) is an independent insurance agencies in the Midwest.

Anthem

Everence Federal Credit Union

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Everence helps individuals, organizations, and congregations integrate finances with faith through a team of advisors and representatives.

Anthem

Express Funeral Funding

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Express Funeral Funding provides insurance assignment funding services for funeral homes and cemeteries.

Anthem

WalkerHughes Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

WalkerHughes Insurance is a professional insurance company that is a pioneer in the insurance sector, providing advice and advocacy.

Anthem

Majestic Care

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Majestic Care is a health care centre specialized in community based skilled nursing throughout clinical services.

Anthem

West End Bank, S.B.

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

West End Bank is a bank that provides business banking, credit cards, mortgages, and auto loans.

Anthem

One Resource Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

One Resource Group is an insurance company providing disability insurance.

Anthem

WorldTrips

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

WorldTrips provides a wide range of travel medical insurance plans for individuals, group, businesses and students.

Anthem

OneIndiana Financial Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

OneIndiana Financial Group is an insurance and financial services agency that provides comprehensive and personal service.

Anthem

Federal Home Loan Bank of Indianapolis

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Federal Home Loan Bank of Indianapolis is a wholesale banking institution that offers liquidity.

Anthem

Oak Street Holdings

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

A Carmel, Ind.-based commercial finance platform focused on insurance industry financing

Anthem

Independent Alliance Banks, Inc.

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Independent Alliance Banks, Inc. provides banking services.

Anthem

HBG Insurance & Bonds

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

HBG Insurance & Bonds, a privately-owned bonding agency.

Anthem

Iip

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Innovative Insurance Partners is a new insurance brokerage firm

Anthem

INGUARD

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

INGUARD is an insurance company providing risk management consultancy services.

Anthem

Boat Holdings

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Boat Holdings is a privately held boat company founded in 1997.

Anthem

American Specialty Insurance & Risk Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

American Specialty Insurance & Risk Services provides insurance and risk services for the sports and entertainment industry.

Anthem

MDwise

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

MDwise is a non-profit agency that assists people in obtaining health insurance and coverage through health-based plans.

Anthem

Swivyl

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Insurtech platform addressing common communication challenges between businesses and their business insurance providers.

Anthem

MRC Billing

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

MRC Billing is providing a comprehensive insurance billing and insurance enrollment for ABA, speech and occupational therapists.

Anthem

Voldico

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Voldico is a financial services and insurance company located in Osgood.

Anthem

Nyhart

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Nyhart is an actuarial and employee benefit firm based in Indiana.

Anthem

On Target Health

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

On Target Health is a Health, Wellness & Fitness platform managing individuals weight & health & fitness through proper diet & exercise.

Anthem

The Merchants Trust

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Merchants Trust is a large British investment trust dedicated to investments in higher yielding FTSE 100 companies.

Anthem

Ball Insurance Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Ball Insurance Services has provided excellent service and incredibly low prices to customers.

Anthem

Priority Risk Management

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Priority Risk Management is an insurance company that offers risk management, employee benefits, life insurance & commercial auto insurance.

Anthem

MBAH Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

MBAH Insurance operates as an insurance agency.

Anthem

Stewart C. Miller & Co

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Stewart C. Miller & Co is a third party administrator of health and pension benefits financial services company located in Lafayette.

Anthem

CommunityWide Federal Credit Union

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

CommunityWide Federal Credit Union provides financial, loans, insurance, and security services.

Anthem

SIHO Insurance Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

SIHO Insurance Services is an insurance company that provides complete health benefit services to small, medium, and large employers.

Anthem

SLS Strategies

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

SLS Strategies has made the investment process as simple, transparent and intuitive as possible.

Anthem

Choice Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Choice Insurance Agency provides a full range of insurance products, including Auto Insurance, Business Insurance, Life Insurance etc

Anthem

Notre Dame Federal Credit Union

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Notre Dame Federal Credit Union offers loans, credit, insurance, banking and financial services.

Anthem

MSI (Mortgage Services III, LLC)

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

MSI is a financial services company offering mortgage services in Bloomington, Chicago, Milwaukee, and Indianapolis areas.

Anthem

McGowan Insurance Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

McGowan Insurance Group is an independent agency and a committed resource serving company located in Indianapolis.

Anthem

HOMETOWN INSURANCE AGENCY

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Hometown Insurance Agency is an insurance company that offers property, and casualty insurance services.

Anthem

WolfeRich Insurance Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

WolfeRich Insurance Group is an insurance provider firm that delivers general, home, auto insurance and life insurance services.

Anthem

Insurance Management Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

An insurance agency

Anthem

Caitlin Morgan Insurance Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Caitlin Morgan Insurance Services helps independent agents nationwide develop package programs for select industry niches.

Anthem

Automated Group Administration

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Automated Group Administration is a third-party service provider that offers managing, funding and administering employee benefit programs.

Anthem

Oberlin Marketing

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Oberlin Marketing is a marketing organization specializes in distribution of insurance products service.

Anthem

Gardner & White Corp.

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Gardner & White Corp. provides employee benefit program consulting services and insurance brokerage services.

Anthem

40/86 Advisors

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

40|86 Advisors is a financial service company that offers investment management, retirement income strategies & financial advisory services.

Anthem

Industrial Federal Credit Union

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Industrial Federal Credit Union offers banking, insurance, mortgages, credit cards, recreational and student loans.

Anthem

ISU Insurance and Investment Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

ISU Insurance and Investment Group is an independent insurance agency.

Anthem

Beast Chassis

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Beast Chassis is one of the most celebrated car builders & team managers in USAC racing history.

Anthem

Brett Huber – State Farm Insurance Agent

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Insurance Agent in Portage, IN

Anthem

Coliance Risk Advisors

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Coliance Risk Advisors is provides insurance brokerage services.

Anthem

Life Settlement Advisors

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Life Settlement Advisors offer sound advice to every client or advisor.

Anthem

Creative Underwriters

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Creative Underwriters provide Special Lines Coverage availability to our Franchised Producer Brokers in need of Special Lines Coverages.

Anthem

AAA Hoosier Motor Club

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

AAA Hoosier Motor Club offers membership, roadside assistance, insurance, travel and financial services.

Anthem

Hahn Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Hahn Insurance Agency is an insurance company that provides home, auto, business, and life insurance services.

Anthem

Meyers Glaros Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Meyers Glaros Group specializes in employee benefits, commercial insurance, and personal insurance services.

Anthem

Green Owens Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Green Owens Insurance Agency is a privately owned independent insurance agency.

Anthem

Insurance Brokers of Indiana

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Insurance Brokers of Indiana is a banking company located in Greenwood.

Anthem

Agency Associates

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Agency Associates offers personal insurance products, including auto, home, health, life, and disability insurance.

Anthem

Federal Insurance Company

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Federal Insurance Company provides property and casualty insurance products and services for businesses and individuals.

Anthem

United Farm Family

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

United Farm Family is a wide platform that specializes in extending its services for families and individuals seeking financial protection.

Anthem

Salem Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Salem Insurance Agency provides all types of individual and business insurance services.

Anthem

Search Pros

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Search Pros has provided highly accurate nationwide canvasses with a quick turnaround time, located in Indiana.

Anthem

Wetzel Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Wetzel Insurance Agency offers all kinds of insurance services that include personal, business, and health insurance.

Anthem

Source Insurance Group & Financial Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Source is a company which provides home insurance, life insurance, business insurance, health insurance and financial services.

Anthem

The Shead Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Medicare Insurance in Anderson, IN

Anthem

Conner Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Conner Insurance is an insurance brokerage firm that specializes in commercial insurance, employee benefits & personal insurance.

Anthem

CarrierHQ

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

CarrierHQ provides motor carrier insurance, factoring, and business formation services.

Anthem

Manhattan National Life Insurance Co.

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Manhattan National Life Insurance Co. provides life insurance products.

Anthem

A 1 Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

A 1 Insurance Agency is a commercial insurance company that specializes in Insurance for professional services.

Anthem

Health Insurance Shop

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Health insurance shop is a company who handles all types of life insurance and health insurance needs for individuals and businesses.

Anthem

PMG Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

PMG Agency is a firm that focuses in health, dental, life, and disability insurance, as well as health insurers who are eager in your firm.

Anthem

Arlington Dental Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Arlington Dental Group is a health care company located in Indianapolis.

Anthem

Noble Consulting Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Noble Consulting Services offers information systems, cybersecurity, enterprise risk management, reinsurance and liquidation services.

Anthem

Administrative Strategies

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Administrative Strategies offers claims adjustment, inspection, and TPA services and resources.

Anthem

Northeast Indiana Innovation Center

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Northeast Indiana Innovation Center is a technology business incubator and venture accelerator.

Anthem

American Trust Investment Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

American Trust Investment Services offers financial services featuring asset allocation, retirement planning and investment products.

Anthem

Truck Insure

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Truck Insure provides commercial truck insurance.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Don't Miss

Meet United States’s 101 Top VP’s in the Big Data Space

At Best Startup US we track over 1,000,000 US startups

Fayetteville’s Finest: A Tour of Top Dental Practices and Services in WV

Cassis Dental Center DentalWebsites.com Dr. Carl Hansen, DDS Jarrell Patrick